Tell Me More: A Content Analysis of Expanded Auditor Reporting in the United Kingdom

by Kecia Williams Smith

Institution: Texas A&M University
Year: 2016
Keywords: communication value; audit report; readability; tone; audit standards; United Kingdom
Posted: 02/05/2017
Record ID: 2096914
Full text PDF: http://hdl.handle.net/1969.1/157843


This study examines the effect of expanded audit disclosures required by ISA 700 (UK and Ireland), The Independent Auditor?s Report on Financial Statements, on the communication value of the audit report. The new ISA 700 audit report is the first attempt by an auditing standard-setter to include expanded auditor disclosure in the audit report. The expanded disclosures significantly alter the pass/fail audit report model; however, it is not immediately clear that more audit report disclosures improve communication value. I address whether communication value improves in the post-ISA 700 by hand-collecting audit report content and demographic data from premium-listed London Stock Exchange and Irish Stock Exchange listed companies. Using content analysis measures, readability and tone, as proxies for communication value, I find that in the post-ISA 700 period: 1) audit report readability improves and 2) audit report tone changes with a higher occurrence of negative and uncertain words. I also evaluate analyst behavior in response to the ISA 700 audit report. I find that analyst following and analyst forecast dispersion decrease in the post-ISA 700 period. In additional analyses, I show that Big N and industry expert auditors write audit reports that are more readable. I also find that domain-specific word dictionaries, generated from Form-10Ks and earnings press releases, have a lower frequency in audit reports in both the pre and post ISA 700 period. With the heightened global interest in improving the historical pass/fail audit report, these results show that expanded audit disclosures can be communicated in a manner that is accessible and meaningful to the financial statement user. Advisors/Committee Members: Wang, Dechun (advisor), Rice, Sarah (committee member), Wolfe, Christopher (committee member), Schleicher, Deidra (committee member).